Legalising Euthanasia: For and Against

Euthanasia, a form of assisted suicide through the help of medical professionals is a topic of controversy as there are many different perspectives to the matter. Here we'll outline more information to give a better understanding and arguments from both supporting/opposing sides.

Last day of Summer by (Deviantart link) Blixx-a

Euthanasia is also referred as an act of 'mercy killing'. It is the practice of ending a life with the intent to free one of suffering, pain and illness. The laws on Euthanasia vary from country to country, state to state. In most places, the procedure is only permitted when operated under certain conditions, while in other countries it may be completely illegal to carry out the procedure.

Euthanasia is classified as voluntary, non voluntary and involuntary. It has been debated whether or not non voluntary is counted as euthanasia due to the fact that those patients can't make a decision for themselves. e.g coma, someone in a vegetative state or children too young to make a decision. Involuntary euthanasia is illegal and often discriminated worldwide due to the fact it is performed on an individual who could give consent. 

Active and Passive Euthanasia

The procedure is classified as active or passive. Passive euthanasia is a gradual process such as a patient discontinuing their medication, turning off life support etc. This procedure is more recognised and supported. In turn, active euthanasia is where a patient is given a direct dosage of lethal injection.

Countries and states that allow Euthanasia

- Belgium
- Luxembourg
- Colombia
- Netherlands
- France

Assisted suicide is legal in: Canada, Switzerland, Germany, Japan and some states in the US (Oregon, Colorado, Vermont, Montana, Washington DC, and California). Although the procedure is illegal in most countries/states, many offer alternate options such as hospice.

For and Against

Against 
Ulterior motives
The procedure is open to abuse. Hence, even in someone's dying moments, there are those who put themselves first and have ulterior motivations behind their actions.

The definition and motives behind Euthanasia has been a topic of debate. The issue is whether or not people with ulterior motives can or rather, will they take advantage of the system. To start off with, euthanasia must be 'solely in the best interest of the one who is receiving it'. But it opens up a loophole, the possibility of alternate motivations from another party (receiving inheritance etc).

Religious aspects

In many cultures and beliefs, God plays as a significant role in life, death and suffering. Suffering is often regarded as a 'test' of faith from God. Many people believe that after enduring the suffering and hardship comes reward. Another belief is that God is the only one who should be able to decide when we die. Euthanasia is a form of suicide so thats against most religious morals/believes. Furthermore, it is believed that euthanasia devalues life and give people the impression that suicide is the 'better' way out.

Elevate suicide rates

 

Lost in the world by (Deviantart link) Axcy

For

The right to die
" Where is your humanity?"

People often talk about the right to a life, but what about the right to die? To allow someone the right to end their suffering in rational and appropriate conditions is only humane. The primary reason to legalise euthanasia is to relive pain and suffering for both the patient and their caretakers. Putting ourselves in their shoes and the perspective of those around them, watching someone we deeply care about suffer, the thought itself is painstaking.

No one wants to burden their loved ones, no one wants to die painfully. Thus, the very least we can do is respect other people's decision.

Reality of the matter

Euthanasia is a form of medically assisted suicide. Yet someone who is endlessly suffering, unable to be dependent or move should be entitled to euthanasia. Both their physical and mental state is disintegrating, and no longer could them themselves or their love ones watch on. As a result, this can be a burden both financially and emotionally. On average, a day in intensive care amounts to $4000+ (can vary in different countries). In this time, the money used could be spend on another cause (such as donating it etc). All it does is prolong the inevitable from happening.

"Despite the initial reaction that money should not be taken into consideration for a human life, the truth of the matter is that in our world today this has become a reality"

 

Some overall thoughts

In conclusion, there are many sides and different opinions on the topic, and throughout the countless debates, we as a society have pointed out major loopholes and flaws but also raised concern over our moral believes and humanity. What will we let define us?

(Bleach, anime scene)
Fading to ash

Questions: 

What are your thoughts on Euthanasia?

Are you for or against? Why?

3 Replies to “Legalising Euthanasia: For and Against”

  1. I support Euthanasia.
    “The right to die” i really like this statement in your article. I think it’s better to just let it all go and achieve eternal rest finally, than suffer. If the patient even wants to end this pain, then why stop him/her from doing so? This , of course, only “easy” when the patient can decide.
    If he/she doesn’t has the ability to make decisions, then it’s up to one’s family i assume. Vegetative state is like death, in it’s case euthanasia is like a redemption.
    Coma is a little different imo, there is a chance to recover.
    Ulterior motives are indeed dangerous. Most likely this is the thing which makes it harder to decide whether it’s the good thing to do, or not so.

  2. Gallu, lol cutesy name.

    What are your thoughts on Euthanasia?

    – I support it to be honest, ‘ 0 ‘)b it’s cool. You can do that once you’ve enjoyed everything in life, and finally do it when you come of a certain age rather than suffering during old age. Less trouble for you and even for the people who need to take care of you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *